data as of built 7 bands 8,590 shows

seven bands, one scale

Comparison

What seven bands played at their concerts, side by side, from the setlists on setlist.fm: how old the songs were, how much the shows changed from one night to the next and how long songs kept being played. The same measures and the same axes for every band.

How old the songs were: repertoire age by year

How old the songs played on each night were, on average, counted from each song's release: at 6, the average song of the show was six years old. Each line is one band. A line that climbs is a band leaning on older material; a line that drops is a new album taking over the set.

Repertoire age by year, all bandsLine chart of average repertoire age by year for the seven bands. The data table below lists every value. 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Years since release Arctic Monkeys Oasis Linkin Park Twenty One Pilots Muse Metallica Avenged Sevenfold
Average repertoire age of the songs played in each year, weighted by how often each song was played.
Data table
YearArctic MonkeysOasisLinkin ParkTwenty One PilotsMuseMetallicaAvenged Sevenfold
1982–––––0.0–
1983–––––0.7–
1984–––––1.4–
1985–––––2.3–
1986–––––1.7–
1987–––––2.7–
1988–––––2.7–
1989–––––3.5–
1990–––––5.1–
1991–0.0–––4.5–
1992–0.4–––5.1–
1993–0.0–––6.1–
1994–0.4–––8.5–
1995–0.8––0.08.4–
1996–1.5––0.07.8–
1997–1.2––0.08.0–
1998–2.6––0.17.9–
1999–3.9––0.39.1–
2000–4.10.1–1.19.5–
2001–5.61.2–0.9–0.4
2002–4.22.2–1.214.50.8
20030.05.01.7–1.214.00.8
20040.07.02.6–2.213.71.4
20050.75.93.5–2.515.30.9
20061.47.34.6–2.317.81.8
20071.510.83.5–3.219.51.8
2008–7.44.30.04.417.22.2
20091.89.14.90.03.415.33.0
20102.7–3.40.54.518.72.2
20113.1–4.71.05.821.93.4
20123.9–6.01.44.223.24.7
20133.8–6.82.15.125.24.0
20143.9–6.43.08.225.15.4
2015––8.12.07.125.06.9
2016––7.03.37.123.58.0
2017––8.03.68.820.27.1
20186.4––2.68.819.98.0
20197.4––3.18.322.4–
2020–––0.0–27.4–
2021–––4.6–29.9–
202210.2––6.011.932.3–
202310.8––7.810.825.48.2
2024––15.76.513.126.210.2
2025–30.113.66.214.629.712.8
2026––14.85.713.631.111.5

How much shows change: rotation by year

Rotation measures how much a band changes its setlist from one show to the next on the same tour. Near 0, the band plays practically the same show every night; above 0.5, more than half of the songs across two consecutive nights appear on only one of them; near 1, almost nothing repeats. Each line is one band.

Rotation by year, all bandsLine chart of rotation by year for the seven bands. The data table below lists every value. 1990 2000 2010 2020 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Rotation (0 = same setlist) Arctic Monkeys Oasis Linkin Park Twenty One Pilots Muse Metallica Avenged Sevenfold
Rotation between consecutive shows of the same tour, by year. Hollow markers: years with fewer than 5 show pairs, left out of the line.
Data table
YearArctic MonkeysOasisLinkin ParkTwenty One PilotsMuseMetallicaAvenged Sevenfold
1983–––––0.08–
1984–––––0.05–
1985–––––0.14–
1986–––––0.13–
1987–––––0.01–
1988–––––0.06–
1989–––––0.22–
1991–––––0.07–
1992–––––0.08–
1993–––––0.08–
1994–0.26–––0.03–
1995–0.23–––––
1996–0.11–––0.13–
1997–0.06–––0.20–
1998–0.09–––0.09–
1999––––0.580.05–
2000–0.090.26–0.360.13–
2001–0.070.17–0.14––
2002–0.090.10–0.11–0.52
2003–0.080.11–0.160.240.55
2004––0.10–0.170.390.62
20050.340.06––0.18–0.44
20060.240.02––0.210.160.56
20070.23–0.12–0.220.330.49
2008–0.010.26–0.250.410.22
20090.110.020.02–0.120.500.17
20100.10–0.180.580.190.570.05
20110.09–0.190.760.320.200.17
20120.05–0.170.520.340.140.17
20130.11–0.280.440.330.500.05
20140.08–0.190.250.42*0.220.16
2015––0.100.230.230.320.06
2016–––0.150.270.23–
2017––0.140.030.240.340.17
20180.17––0.000.580.370.16
20190.10––0.070.070.32–
2021–––0.34–––
20220.12––0.100.140.30–
20230.14–––0.180.870.04
2024––0.140.02–0.850.17
2025–0.000.280.030.290.620.12
2026––0.31–0.130.620.02

How long songs last: median survival by band

How many shows a song lasts in the live repertoire, counted from its live debut to its last appearance. The median is the number of shows after which half of a band's songs have been abandoned; it is not reached when fewer than half ever are. The last column converts the median into years of touring using each band's average shows per year in the data, counting only years with shows; it is an approximate calculation.

BandSongsAbandonedCensored (still played, or came back)Median (shows)Approximate equivalent
Arctic Monkeys905436337about 5 years
Oasis804931163about 4 years
Linkin Park985840265about 6 years
Twenty One Pilots934944674about 12 years
Muse1258441480about 10 years
Metallica10762451,235about 26 years
Avenged Sevenfold714427463about 10 years

Measured in shows, not in time (see Methodology): a band that plays more shows a year gets through the same number of shows in less time. Abandoned means the song left the setlist for at least 50 shows and did not return; censored means it is still played, or it returned.