data as of built 7 bands 8,590 shows

band profile

Metallica

What Metallica played at its concerts, night after night, from the setlists on setlist.fm; the discography comes from MusicBrainz.

What stands out

Metallica went from a nearly fixed show in the 1980s to one that changes a lot, and its setlist got younger after each of its last three albums.

Rotation (how much the setlist changes from one show to the next) rose from 0.09 in its first three years with enough shows (1983, 1984 and 1985) to 0.70 in its last three. On the M72 World Tour (2023–2026) it reached 0.75, partly by design of the tour (see the context below and the caveats). Its average repertoire age (how old the songs played were) fell 6.9 years around 72 Seasons (2023), and similar falls appeared around Death Magnetic (2008) and Hardwired… to Self-Destruct (2016).

Context, not something the data proves: in the 1980s the set was nearly fixed; since the 2000s its tours have varied more, and M72 took that to the limit with the 'No Repeat Weekend' format.

Caveats and limits
  • On the M72 World Tour Metallica plays two consecutive nights in the same city with different setlists (the 'No Repeat Weekend' format), so much of this high rotation is by design of the tour. That is public context about the tour: the aggregated data carries no cities, so it neither confirms nor rules out the explanation. What it does show is that no song was played at 9 in 10 shows of the tour.
  • The format does not explain everything: Metallica's rotation was already 0.52 on World Magnetic (2008–2010), and it was 0.87 in 2023 and 0.85 in 2024.
  • The overall median survival is 1,235 shows (about 26 years); 50 shows cover a different stretch of time for each band, so compare with care (see Methodology).
  • Ride the Lightning lost 1 of 7 songs and kept 86% after 2,074 shows (about 43 years); Kill 'Em All lost 7 of 10, but only after a median of 2,005 shows (about 42 years).
  • The data shows that Metallica's rotation rose, not why, and a dip in repertoire age around an album release does not show that the release caused it (see the home page).
  • The conversion of shows into years uses Metallica's average shows per year in the data (about 48, counting only years with shows and only the shows on setlist.fm) and is approximate.
  • Survival is counted in shows, not years, and years with fewer than 5 pairs of consecutive shows are left out of rotation. Only discography songs (found in MusicBrainz) played at least 3 times enter survival (see Methodology).

How old the songs were: repertoire age

Average, in years, between each song's release and the night it was played, weighted by how often each song was played. Near 0, the band plays freshly released material; at 6, the average song of the show was six years old. There is a single line here, Metallica's: rising, the set leans on older material; falling, newer songs took over.

Metallica: repertoire age by yearLine chart of the average repertoire age of Metallica by year. The data table below lists every value. 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Years since release
Average repertoire age by year, weighted by how often each song was played.
Data table
YearMetallica
19820.0
19830.7
19841.4
19852.3
19861.7
19872.7
19882.7
19893.5
19905.1
19914.5
19925.1
19936.1
19948.5
19958.4
19967.8
19978.0
19987.9
19999.1
20009.5
200214.5
200314.0
200413.7
200515.3
200617.8
200719.5
200817.2
200915.3
201018.7
201121.9
201223.2
201325.2
201425.1
201525.0
201623.5
201720.2
201819.9
201922.4
202027.4
202129.9
202232.3
202325.4
202426.2
202529.7
202631.1

Median age by tour

Each bar is one tour in one year (a tour that spans several years appears once per year) and shows the median age of the songs played: half were that old or younger. The diamond marks the mean. A low bar means an almost entirely recent repertoire; a high bar, a lean on old songs. Tours with fewer than 15 shows in a year are left out.

Metallica: median repertoire age by tourBar chart of the median repertoire age of each tour and year of Metallica. The data table below lists every value. 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 Repertoire age (years) Ride the Lightning 1984 Ride the Lightning 1985 Damage Inc. 1986 Damage Inc. 1987 Damaged Justice 1988 Monsters of Rock 1988 1988 Damaged Justice 1989 Monsters of Rock 1991 1991 Wherever We May Roam 1991 1992 North American Tour 1992 Wherever We May Roam 1992 Nowhere Else to Roam 1993 Wherever We May Roam 1993 Shit Hits the Sheds 1994 Lollapalooza 1996 1996 Poor Touring Me 1996 Poor Touring Me 1997 Poor Re-Touring Me 1998 Garage Remains the Same 1999 Summer Sanitarium 2000 2000 European Festivals 2003 2003 Madly in Anger with the Wor… 2003 Summer Sanitarium 2003 2003 Madly in Anger with the Wor… 2004 European Summer Vacation 2008 World Magnetic 2008 World Magnetic 2009 World Magnetic 2010 2012 European Black Album T… 2012 2013 Summer Tour 2013 Metallica by Request 2014 Worldwired 2017 Worldwired 2018 Worldwired 2019 M72 World Tour 2023 M72 World Tour 2024 M72 World Tour 2025 M72 World Tour 2026 mean
Median repertoire age of each tour and year; the diamond is the mean.
Data table
TourYearShowsMedian ageMean age
Ride the Lightning19842511.3
Ride the Lightning19853722.3
Damage Inc.198610621.7
Damage Inc.19872632.7
Damaged Justice19886422.5
Monsters of Rock 198819882743.6
Damaged Justice198914433.5
Monsters of Rock 199119911955.3
Wherever We May Roam19913434.2
1992 North American Tour19922645.2
Wherever We May Roam199214145.0
Nowhere Else to Roam19932476.5
Wherever We May Roam19935356.0
Shit Hits the Sheds19945198.5
Lollapalooza 199619962267.3
Poor Touring Me19965788.0
Poor Touring Me19977978.1
Poor Re-Touring Me19986087.9
Garage Remains the Same19994499.4
Summer Sanitarium 2000200020109.7
European Festivals 20032003191614.4
Madly in Anger with the World2003201513.6
Summer Sanitarium 20032003201513.9
Madly in Anger with the World20041161613.7
European Summer Vacation2008202220.8
World Magnetic2008261814.6
World Magnetic2009901915.2
World Magnetic2010632218.7
2012 European Black Album Tour2012162222.9
2013 Summer Tour2013232725.2
Metallica by Request2014252625.1
Worldwired2017562720.1
Worldwired2018472819.7
Worldwired2019412922.4
M72 World Tour2023263325.7
M72 World Tour2024283426.2
M72 World Tour2025293529.2
M72 World Tour2026163631.1

How much shows change: rotation

Rotation measures how much the setlist changes from one show to the next on the same tour, by year. Near 0, the band plays practically the same show every night; above 0.5, more than half of the songs across two consecutive nights appear on only one of them; near 1, almost nothing repeats. There is a single line here, Metallica's: falling, the show became more fixed; rising, more changeable.

Metallica: rotation by yearLine chart of the rotation of Metallica by year. The data table below lists every value. 1990 2000 2010 2020 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Rotation (0 = same setlist)
Rotation between consecutive shows of the same tour. Hollow markers: years with fewer than 5 show pairs, left out of the line.
Data table
YearMetallica
19830.08
19840.05
19850.14
19860.13
19870.01
19880.06
19890.22
19910.07
19920.08
19930.08
19940.03
19960.13
19970.20
19980.09
19990.05
20000.13
20030.24
20040.39
20060.16
20070.33
20080.41
20090.50
20100.57
20110.20
20120.14
20130.50
20140.22
20150.32
20160.23
20170.34
20180.37
20190.32
20220.30
20230.87
20240.85
20250.62
20260.62

How long songs last: survival

Each line follows the songs of one studio album from the night they were first played live, and its height is the share still in the setlist (100% at the start). A high, flat line means the songs stayed; a steep drop means they left quickly. The axis counts shows, not years: for Metallica, which in the years it played averages about 48 shows a year, 100 shows are about 2 years of touring. The grey line marks half. Metallica crosses that mark, that is, loses half of its songs, at 1,235 shows, about 26 years of touring.

Metallica: song survival by albumKaplan-Meier curves of the share of songs still played after t shows, one per album, for Metallica. The data table below gives the share at 25, 50, 100, 200 and 400 shows. 0 250 500 750 1000 1250 1500 1750 2000 Shows since debut 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Share still in the setlist median 72 Seasons (9 songs) Death Magnetic (9 songs) Hardwired… to Self‐Destruct (9 songs) Kill ’Em All (10 songs) Load (8 songs) Master of Puppets (8 songs) Metallica (self-titled album) (12 songs) Reload (6 songs) Ride the Lightning (7 songs) St. Anger (6 songs) …And Justice for All (9 songs) non-album (14 songs) All songs (107 songs)
Kaplan-Meier curves. A song counts as abandoned when it stays out of the setlist for 50 shows or more without coming back; the dashed line combines all the discography songs analysed.
Data table
Albumafter 25 showsafter 50 showsafter 100 showsafter 200 showsafter 400 shows
72 Seasons (9 songs)89%89%89%––
Death Magnetic (9 songs)100%100%100%67%33%
Hardwired… to Self‐Destruct (9 songs)100%89%89%22%–
Kill ’Em All (10 songs)100%100%100%100%100%
Load (8 songs)100%88%88%75%75%
Master of Puppets (8 songs)100%100%100%100%100%
Metallica (self-titled album) (12 songs)100%100%100%100%75%
Reload (6 songs)100%100%83%83%83%
Ride the Lightning (7 songs)100%100%100%100%100%
St. Anger (6 songs)83%67%67%67%67%
…And Justice for All (9 songs)100%100%100%100%89%
non-album (14 songs)86%64%64%57%34%
All songs (107 songs)96%91%90%79%68%

Albums

Discography songs played at least 3 times, by reference album (the earliest studio album that contains the song). Median survival is in shows.

AlbumSongsAbandonedCensored (still played, or came back)Median (shows)
All songs10762451,235
72 Seasons918not reached
Death Magnetic972289
Hardwired… to Self‐Destruct972150
Kill ’Em All10732,005
Load8621,068
Master of Puppets835not reached
Metallica (self-titled album)1257not reached
Reload624not reached
Ride the Lightning716not reached
St. Anger660736
…And Justice for All9541,458
non-album14122262

Other bands